• Inquiries
  • About
  • Travel With Me
  • Nav Social Menu

    • Bloglovin
    • LinkedIn
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter

Cotten Tales

  • MY GIRLS
    • DOROTHY
    • FRANCES
  • MOCO FIXER
  • STITCH FIX

22 | Stitch Fix Caribbean Edition

Stitch Fix

23 Jun

Want to learn more about Stitch Fix? Start at the beginning for all the details, and then check out my past reviews.

—

We’re going to the islands, mon!

If you remember, my husband received the “Best Husband in the History of EVER” award when he surprised me with a Caribbean vacation on our anniversary. There is no place I love more than the white sands and turquoise waters!

Lucky for me, I had a monthly Stitch Fix box arriving right before we are due to leave on a jet plane. I sent a quick note to my stylist requesting anything that screams “sun, sand and never-ending piña coladas,” because a trip to the beach requires a few new outfits! Specifically, I requested something that could double as a cover up – like a kimono – and lightweight beachy dresses.

I had high hopes for this Fix, since Stitch Fix has been promoting vacation style on their own blog, and my Pinterest board has pretty much been on point. However, when I sneaked a peak at my shipment before it arrived, I was disappointed to see no kimonos, no maxi dresses, no printed shorts or palazzo pants, and THREE Pixley items. Not that I don’t like Pixley, but a variety would have been nice! In fact, I’m pretty positive that Stylist Julie didn’t read my note or look at my pins, since nothing I received seems super appropriate for a tropical getaway.

Boo.

Typically I request input from all of you before making my final decision on what keep and what to return, but due to the timing of this shipment I had to make my selections all by myself (with the help of my Mr., because let’s be honest – it’s him I’m looking to impress anyway!).

With that, let’s take a look at my June 2015 Stitch Fix review – {almost} Caribbean Edition!

—

Pixley Hillway Double Strap Tank – S – $48

DSC_1448

I really want to like this tank, but it’s hard. I love the halter-like neckline, as I’ve noted in my last few Fixes. However, the high-low hem isn’t really my favorite. The “high” is too short for the majority of the shorts I own. Stylist Julie suggested skinny jeans… which is not very Caribbean, in my opinion.

I am a fan of the colors and print. Of all the pieces in this Fix, this top is the most appropriate for the beach bar… but I just can’t make myself like the cut.

VERDICT: Returned

Color: Red
My Pairings:
Necklace | Stitch Fix
Shorts | Old Navy (old)
Sandals | Target

 

Romolo Douglas Fringe Cord Necklace – $54

DSC_1470

This necklace is a lot heavier than I expected – which is equivalent to quality where I’m from. However, for something made from beads and a leather braid, this is extremely overpriced. I have jewelry and accessories marked as “The cheaper, the better” in my style profile. $54 is absolutely ridiculous.

VERDICT: Returned

Color: Silver
My Pairings:
Earrings | Stella & Dot
Tank | Target
Pants | Target (my husband told me they look like his grandma’s couch, but for $5 I love them!)
Watch | JORD Wood Watch

 

Pixley Karolina Spaghetti Strap Polka Dot Dress – S – $68

DSC_1438

While this dress is my husband’s favorite from the box, I initially wasn’t a fan. Once I got past the fact that this in no way screams “CARIBBEAN” (huge disappointment!), I realized that I do like this piece for other occasions, or a fancy French dinner on the island. I’m a sucker for polka dots, and I like the retro vibe in the neckline… I’m just not overly crazy about the way it accentuates my baby making hips.

VERDICT: Keep! Apparently the husband likes my hips. 😉

Color: Navy
My Pairings:
Necklace | Stella & Dot
Shoes | way too ancient to remember

 

Gilli Regan Striped Maxi Skirt – S – $58

DSC_1461

I’m shocked to say that I like this maxi skirt. I’ve previously given negative reviews to jersey maxis from Stitch Fix, simply because I think they’re overpriced. I can normally get a similar skirt at Target for half the cost. However, the Gilli Regan skirt is partially lined, is super soft, and I could definitely get away with wearing this on the island. I just wish it was a different, more flowy fabric (and cheaper). Plus, I already own a purple maxi skirt.

VERDICT: Returned

Color: Purple
My Pairings:
Necklace | Gordmans
Tank | Target
Watch | JORD Wood Watch

 

Pixley Priya Diamond Printed Knit Back Tank – S – $54

DSC_1456

I adore the colors and pattern of this tank. Throughout my Stitch Fix journey, I’ve realized I’m definitely more of a cool colors girl. I know I could get a ton of use out of this top, however I’m not sure I can get over the price! Like, really? $54 seems high for this basic of tank. Plus – dry clean only for the beach? Ha. That’s a good one.

VERDICT: Returned

Color: Green
My Pairings:
Necklace | Stitch Fix
Shorts | Clothing Swap Score!
Watch | JORD Wood Watch
Shoes | vintage, Hot House Market

 

—

To be honest, I’m super unhappy with this Fix. I couldn’t have been more specific with what I was looking for, yet the items I received look like this could have been my first shipment… not my 22nd. Some of the items are okay for every day, but they aren’t at all what I was looking for in terms of vacation. I didn’t keep anything from my last box, and I don’t love anything from this one. And I was having such good luck! I hate to be “that person,” but I definitely sent an email to Stitch Fix to request a different stylist.

Am I in the wrong here? Let me know your thoughts!

To sign up for your own Stitch Fix, click here. Please note that this post is not sponsored by Stitch Fix however I do receive a credit if you sign up using my link.

 

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

2 Comments

Previous Post: « Oh hey, Friday.
Next Post: Fashionably Adulting | JORD Wood Watch »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Heather Hammel says

    June 23, 2015 at 7:37 am

    I don’t think you’re in the wrong here. You couldn’t have been more specific in what you wanted. I was using esalon for my hair dye for a while because I loved that it is customized, however, when I put in a note for my next shipment to be a deep burgundy (I’ve dyed my hair burgundy from store bought hair dye and loved it but wanted to see if they could give me a better quality dye) and they definitely did not listen at all. It was not burgundy. So I stopped the shipments and picked up the hair dye I buy at the store.

    http://dogmomchic.blogspot.com/

    Reply
  2. Lindsay @ Wild Ginger Blog says

    July 2, 2015 at 1:21 am

    good choices. PS you are basically rockin’ that dress. Good keep!

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Hey there, I'm Samantha. Recovering SAHM, and aspiring competitive dance mom. I have a passion for travel, am known to say it like it is, and I most certainly do not have it all together. Currently on a journey toward self love and discovery. Join me. 2021 | Bloom

Latest from Instagram

Definitely not over the @iddancecomp photos from l Definitely not over the @iddancecomp photos from last weekend. 💜🕺
Just like that, Biddy Ball is over. 😢 We’re S Just like that, Biddy Ball is over. 😢 We’re SO proud of Frances for trying something new, developing as a player each week, and even scoring her first basket in the last minute of her last game! 🏀 We’ll miss our Tuesday and Thursday night games, until next year! #francesbelle
“Play it again, play it again, play it again… “Play it again, play it again, play it again… “ 🎶
Raising ballers. 🏀 Raising ballers. 🏀
That’s a wrap on @artisticdanceexchange! Dorothy That’s a wrap on @artisticdanceexchange! Dorothy received a scholarship toward the national convention in Orlando this summer, and was invited to perform in the junior opening number. 

Long drives, early mornings, and endless hours taking residence in hotel lobbies with my fellow dance parents. We survived Convention month - on to Competition season!
Another weekend, another dance convention. 🩰 Do Another weekend, another dance convention. 🩰 Dorothy had a blast learning in the @activateyourartistry Pre-Pro level, dancing with middle schoolers. One more convention to go… this month. 😜
Follow on Instagram

Follow Me

  • Bloglovin
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Get $25 for Your Stitch Fix!

Stitch Fix

Categories

  • MY GIRLS
  • MOCO FIXER
  • STITCH FIX
Definitely not over the @iddancecomp photos from l Definitely not over the @iddancecomp photos from last weekend. 💜🕺
Just like that, Biddy Ball is over. 😢 We’re S Just like that, Biddy Ball is over. 😢 We’re SO proud of Frances for trying something new, developing as a player each week, and even scoring her first basket in the last minute of her last game! 🏀 We’ll miss our Tuesday and Thursday night games, until next year! #francesbelle
“Play it again, play it again, play it again… “Play it again, play it again, play it again… “ 🎶
Raising ballers. 🏀 Raising ballers. 🏀
That’s a wrap on @artisticdanceexchange! Dorothy That’s a wrap on @artisticdanceexchange! Dorothy received a scholarship toward the national convention in Orlando this summer, and was invited to perform in the junior opening number. 

Long drives, early mornings, and endless hours taking residence in hotel lobbies with my fellow dance parents. We survived Convention month - on to Competition season!
Another weekend, another dance convention. 🩰 Do Another weekend, another dance convention. 🩰 Dorothy had a blast learning in the @activateyourartistry Pre-Pro level, dancing with middle schoolers. One more convention to go… this month. 😜
Natural. Talent. 😂 #biddyball #basketball #funn Natural. Talent. 😂 #biddyball #basketball #funny
Day 1 of @shine_dance_convention! Intensives in Br Day 1 of @shine_dance_convention! Intensives in Broadway Jazz, Lyrical/Contemporary, Hip Hop, Jazz and Tap, plus a Masquerade Ball to end the night. 

We’re tired. 😅
Merry Christmas Eve from the Cotten sisters! ❄️ #dbunny #francesbelle
"Today’s special moments are tomorrow’s memori "Today’s special moments are tomorrow’s memories." —Genie, Aladdin 💙

Copyright © 2023 · Cotten Tales & Samantha Cotten

 

Loading Comments...